Jabariyah and Qadariyah

The history of Islam recognizes Jabariyah and Qadariyah. Both argue that fate has been decided whether by the God or human being.

Obviously, Jabariyah has been claimed that the people do not have any power or freedom at all in making decision or choosing their fate. Although they have a freedom but it does not influence their life. Because the decision maker is only God. For instance, mate, luck, and death. Those have been given by the God.

            Whereas Jabariyah believes that the fate has been given by the God. Qadariyah disputes it. The fate is not decided by the God but human being. Therefore mate, luck and death are on human choices. Having say that human being has an authority to determine their own life or destiny.

            I personally think that Jabariyah and Qadariyah are showing that the different view even though both have the same source. It is holy Qur’an. Also in this case probably happen because of the difficult concept in Islam. So that is why, it is difficult to give which is the true.  On the other hand, regarding some statements above I emphasize that there is the fate we do not have any power to change and there is the fate given by ourselves. For instance, the fate which is impossible to change, such us our gender, man or woman, we cannot change them, even though we do operation. Then, the fate which possible to change is our happiness.

            In conclusion, it is similarly Jabariyah and Qadariyah are islam, for and against which is happening only part of Islam. Then, the scoring maker is only the God.